Thank you so much for all of your feedback on my last newsletter!
I received a bunch of emails and got a ton of great ideas. Overwhelmingly, the most requested topic was butterflies, with a little bit of earnings.
I had one question that I wanted to go ahead and respond to with a newsletter, with plans for more videos later on.
The question was:
Can you do a video (or video series, for that matter) on how to manage butterflies, or other options strategies (e.g. verticals) especially if/when they go against you? For example, say I place a 5-day expiring (call debit) butterfly because I think the market is going up. However, over the next day or so, the market instead tanks. How can I manage the trade to mitigate losses; or hopefully even better, is there a way to trade/manage it into a potential winner?
Want to learn more about butterflies? Click on the image above!
Here is my response:
In general, with a butterfly, the best defense is starting the trade so that it’s in the money. That way, when the market pulls back, it doesn’t lose as much value. If you start off the trade so that it’s at the money or out of the money, it’s a lot cheaper but it loses value very quickly if the market goes against you.
I do place at the money flies, when the market is in a strong trend. If I’m wrong and the market pulls back, and the setup is still working (i.e. there is consolidation but it hasn’t broken out, versus consolidation broke out the wrong direction), then sometimes I will add another butterfly at a lower level that can capitalize quicker when/if the market begins to go higher.
You can also add another fly with a different expiration date. Let’s say for example the market pulled back and now your butterfly probably won’t hit a target in time. You can set another one at a lower price target with a farther-out expiration date, and close the loser or wait to see if it will come back.
Closing vs. waiting depends on your initial risk when you got in. Sometimes, I will target a 50% stop if I’m wrong, but most often I am risking the full debit and not taking a stop. So, if it’s down, I simply wait and if it loses money then I already risked the debit and was comfortable with losing it.
I hope that helps, but I will definitely make some videos!
Friday, June 12, 2026 Traders, Pre-earnings momentum season is heating up, and I’m laser-focused on two distinct types of setups I’m hunting right now. Top-Tier Setups: 4-Star & 5-Star Ranked Tickers These deliver the highest-probability moves because they have proven, repeatable earnings behavior. Live Example: NBIS (4-Star Ranked) NBIS checks every box for a strong … Read more
Wednesday, June 10, 2026 Good morning, Five Star Traders! I love getting ready for summertime trading! We are officially stepping out of the classic June lull and into one of my favorite seasonal setups of the entire year: pre-earnings momentum trading going into July and August. The first two weeks of June can be historically … Read more
Friday, June 5, 2026 Hey Traders, If you’re feeling that sting from today’s Nasdaq drop, take a deep breath. We just saw the Nasdaq futures get hammered, and close down roughly -5.4% on the day, and it continued falling after the cash session closed. It’s this kind of move that I’ll be watching very closely … Read more
